this post was submitted on 22 Jul 2023
91 points (92.5% liked)
Fantasy books, stories, &c
2801 readers
1 users here now
Anything related to the fantasy genre
Related communities
- [email protected]
- [email protected]
- [email protected]
- [email protected]
- [email protected] (also more niche communities)
FAQ
- What does "&c" mean? It's an old-fashioned abbreviation for et cetera.
founded 4 years ago
MODERATORS
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
That list reads more like a "21 books that I've read--with a few girl authors I heard were good or famous or black thrown in".
Brent Weeks is not a great author, and while Jim Butcher is consistent in his output (barring the few years where his RL went to shit on him) his Craft suffers in his non-urban fantasy series. (He coasts a LOT on Harry Dresden's voice and charm and culture references, and doesn't get that crutch in his other series and it shows.) I LIKE Jim Butcher, but there's tons of authors that can write circles around him. His career is based on completing books and getting them out the door, not creating masterworks.
Where's Robin McKinley? Robin Hobb? Kate Elliott, who was writing and COMPLETING her Crown of Stars epic fantasy series at the same time Martin and Jorden were writing (and never completed their series)? Lois McMaster Bujold, whose Challion series is just as good as her Vorkosigan series? Jacqueline Carey? And if we're including YA, which the Hunger Games suggests (although as one person pointed out, those are sci-fi), where's Tamora Pierce? Patricia C. Wrede?
The person who wrote that list reads a very specific part of the genre and leaves a LOT of the greats out.
Ugh, I disliked the Assassin's Apprentice series. It's written like his mentors have some sort of plan for dealing with Royal, when really the entirety of their plan is "let him do whatever he wants, up to and including getting everyone killed and selling out the entire country". That was the most disappointing, limp-dicked arc to a story I've read among books that are considered good by some people. I kind of enjoyed the first book or two while reading it, but I very much wished I had read something else by the time I was done.
Bro Jim has chops I don't think a lot of people respect. I hated BG/PT more than most and am still pretty vocal about how blatant a cash grab it was, but that's just the latest Dresden drip. Go back and look at Codex Alera again. The complexity of plot, the subtle politics and character relationships, and the over the top large scale action. Imo it's pretty great all time fiction work, and it's genesis was a drunken bet about Pokémon and the lost Roman legion. I'm honestly hopeful for the Olympian Affair, as the Cinder Spires series had a very promising start.