this post was submitted on 31 Oct 2023
893 points (99.9% liked)
196
16431 readers
2467 users here now
Be sure to follow the rule before you head out.
Rule: You must post before you leave.
founded 1 year ago
MODERATORS
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
Farming requires a lot more than land
You’re right, it requires people! It’s too bad there’s not an army of people underemployed in exploitative jobs that do not meet their basic needs along with an army of unemployed and often even unhoused people... We could just… pay them living wages to farm… there’s an idea!
Excellent, so we'll need some profits on that food then, to pay them?
Let's keep going with this thinking. We're inventing a system from first principles
Profits aren’t wages, you obviously haven’t read much economics. Profits are what’s left AFTER wages and costs.
You're failing to differentiate between gross and net profits.
Ever run a business?
How is everyone going to afford this food if you're selling it for a gross profit? I believe that was your original point.
Yes, I have run a business haha. Profit doesn’t mean either gross or net profits, it means, and I quote from the dictionary,
That is profit. Now, people can break it down further, but, when someone is referring to profits, you should assume they mean the dictionary definition of profits.
I should, should I?
You previously suggested I've not read enough economics, so should I assume you have? Do they all use that word with that meaning?
Also, I'm wondering if you have an answer to the other question. How is everyone going to afford this food that's being sold even if it doesn't have a markup?
How is anyone going to afford the food that is no longer being marked up? If the food is cheaper, somehow less people will be able to afford it than now? Is that the position you’re coming from?
I’d like to answer your question, it’s just… not really a question that makes any logical sense.
And yes, you should. I can provide plenty of economic texts if you would like to come to understand the economic system you live under. We can even start all the way back with Adam Smith, and move up from there. Like the part where he says that someone holding land without working to improve it does not deserve the land, and should not be allowed to keep it.