this post was submitted on 05 Aug 2023
1 points (100.0% liked)

Hobbit Tolkien Talk

134 readers
2 users here now

Talk about anything Tolkien related.

Don't be afraid to reply to very old posts. Tolkien knowledge has no expiration date.

Please keep things relaxed. We're all hobbits here. If you are a Sackville Baggins, No Admittance Except on Party Business.

founded 1 year ago
MODERATORS
 

So, Frodo puts on the ring while at Amon Hen and within moments, Sauron starts looking toward him. If not for Gandalf's interference, he'd have been seen.

But, mere seconds later, Frodo puts the ring right back on again and heads to the boats and is apparently not seen.

Much later, Sam puts on the ring in Mordor to chase after Frodo, but he's not seen by Sauron. Then, at the last moment, when Frodo puts on the ring in Mt Doom, Sauron is instantly aware.

Putting on the ring in the Shire appears to never alert Sauron, but does alert the black riders when they're close.

I have no doubt that there are rules being applied here. Tolkien never does anything randomly. So, what are the rules? Is there something magical about Amon Hen that made it especially dangerous? Is it simply being on top of a hill so that there's a clear line of sight between Barad-dûr and wherever the ring is?

no comments (yet)
sorted by: hot top controversial new old
there doesn't seem to be anything here