The very best comments on the Fediverse as voted by the users.
I honestly think this community will probably take time to grow because there isn't much best of content here yet. All of us need to focus on bringing content to the fediverse in general in order to improve that. In the meantime, it might work well to focus on the best, most well thought out or educational comments that we come across, as opposed to entire threads.
I know what I don't want to see is reddit content being recycled here.
I agree that a focus on great individual comments seems better than a focus on great threads. I thought the 'best of ' subreddit had a good approach. I really enjoyed reading well thought out comments that really got the to core of the topic at hand.
And in general I assume this community will simply grow organically as size scales up over time and people see nice examples of posts in this magazine.
I honestly think this community will probably take time to grow because there isn't much best of content here yet. All of us need to focus on bringing content to the fediverse in general in order to improve that.
I know this, but part of me feels like this community will stop growing and stagnate if I'm not actively trying to prop it up. You're right though, I need to calm down and just let the waves come and go.
In the meantime, it might work well to focus on the best, most well thought out or educational comments that we come across, as opposed to entire threads.
That's a great point, but I think kbin might be lacking functionality at the moment. We need to be able to provide context when providing a link to a comment.
I know what I don't want to see is reddit content being recycled here.
I can assure you the limited Reddit content we have is temporary. I'm being a bit relax on this rule because of the limited content we're working with.
I can't remember what it's called, but there's a bot on reddit that replies to comments with links to posts if they get linked someplace else. Having a bot like that would be great for here (and other communities)! In lieu of that, I think having people reply to comments saying "I posted this on /m/bestof" with a link to their post (but a bit lengthier, maybe with a set format?) would work as well
I can't wait to have some bots to provide us with some improvements!
Maybe have the poster post the link url in this magazine and then have a bot follow that back to the original post with a reply, saying it had been posted to #bestof ? Also, we should probably encourage #’s more as that’s how kbin propagates things through magazines